Flour compositions formed from portions of coffee cherries and methods for making the same are described. Seeds (or coffee beans) may be removed from coffee cherries to form coffee by-products (also referred to as cherry solids). The cherry solids may be dried and processed to form a powder composition. One or more secondary ingredients may be combined with the powder compositions to form a flour composition. Non-limiting examples of secondary ingredients include proteins, starches, salts, oils, vitamins, and minerals. The powder compositions may be used as a food ingredient and/or as a component of a food ingredient in various edible products.