A sheet feeding mechanism including a pick apparatus for selectively moving a sheet of media from a stack. A kicker is disclosed in several embodiments and serves to retain media on the stack. In a first embodiment, a cam is coupled to the pick apparatus for deflecting the kicker from the first position at which it retains media on the stack to a second position at which paper is allowed to move through the mechanism. In a particular implementation of the first illustrative embodiment, the mechanism includes a frame and a shaft mounted on the frame for rotational movement relative thereto. The pick apparatus includes a pick tire mounted on the shaft and adapted to rotate therewith. The kicker is mounted on the frame for retaining media on the stack in a first position. The cam is adapted to deflect the kicker during a first portion of a rotational cycle and to release the kicker when the cam is in a second rotational position. In a second embodiment, the cam is contoured to provide a protruded edge which engages the kicker when the cam is counter-rotated. This forces the kicker to push media remaining on a separation roll back onto the stack and is particularly well suited for printers utilizing inclined media trays. In a third embodiment, the kicker is mounted on a shaft along with a separation roll. In a specific implementation of this embodiment, the kicker is a flexible strip of plastic that flexes as it engages the stack when the shaft is rotated and after it has rotated around, pushes media remaining on the separation roll back onto the stack. Finally, a fourth embodiment is disclosed by which the kickers are implemented with a plurality of small gravity actuated kickers mounted between two pick tires. The kickers are adapted to fall out of the way when the pick tires are rotating in a first direction and to fall into position to push media back onto the stack when the pick tires are counter-rotated.