A compression moulding tool for manufacturing a fibrous pulp tray (600) having a floor portion (602) and walls (604) extending from the floor portion. The tool comprises a first female mould element (102) comprising a plurality of first recessed portions (112), a water permeable filter (202) arranged in the first female mould element and configured to follow the surface of the female mould element, a second female mould element (104) comprising a plurality of second recessed portions (306) at locations corresponding to the first recessed portions and smaller than the first recessed portions, and a male mould element (106) configured to press against the first and second female mould elements to compress a fibrous pulp product located therebetween, the male mould element having a smooth surface profile at locations corresponding to the first and second recessed portions of the first and second female mould.