An indication of a content item being provided to a channel of a content item sharing platform may be received. Users associated with the channel of the content item sharing platform may be identified. Classifications of feedback of the users that are based on evaluations of the feedback from the plurality of users for other content items on the content item sharing platform may be received. A first portion of the plurality of users associated with a first classification indicating a higher rating than a second portion of the plurality of users associated with a second classification indicating a lower rating may be identified. Notifications identifying the content item may be sent to the first portion of the plurality of users associated with the first classification indicating the higher rating before the second portion associated with the second classification indicating the lower rating.