Consistency metadata, including a parameter for a pseudo-random number source, are determined for training-and-evaluation iterations of a machine learning model. Using the metadata, a first training set comprising records of at least a first chunk is identified from a plurality of chunks of a data set. The first training set is used to train a machine learning model during a first training-and-evaluation iteration. A first test set comprising records of at least a second chunk is identified using the metadata, and is used to evaluate the model during the first training-and-evaluation iteration.