A method for presenting content items includes receiving, by a user device, a request for a media content item hosted by a content sharing platform, and providing, by the user device, a graphical user interface (GUI) comprising a first GUI portion having a first media player to play the requested media content item, and a second GUI portion having a second media player to play an additional media content item associated with a particular portion of the requested media content item. The method further includes in response to the first media player beginning to play the particular portion of the requested media content item, causing the second media player to play the additional media content item.