A method, non-transitory computer readable medium, and data storage computing device that obtains data to be stored in a buffer in a buffer cache, determines a priority of the buffer based on the data, identifies one of a set of global recycle queues based on the priority, and inserts the buffer and metadata into the global recycle queue. When the global recycle queue is determined to be a lowest priority global recycle queue and the buffer is determined to be a least recently used buffer, the buffer is removed from the global recycle queue and inserted into a per-thread recycle queue. When the buffer is least recently used in the per-thread recycle queue, the buffer is removed from the per-thread recycle queue and placed in a free pool. With this technology, buffer cache can be more efficiently managed, particularly with respect to aging and scavenging operations, among other advantages.