Systems and methods for creating and maintaining an interactive time display may include (1) presenting a social media post within a consumption interface of a social media platform, (2) predicting a viewer's response to the post and selecting an automated digital response that coincides with the predicted response, (3) providing a selectable version of the automated digital response within the consumption interface, (4) receiving user input selecting the automated digital response, and (5) in response to receiving the user input, posting the automated digital response to the post. Various other methods, systems, and computer-readable media are also disclosed.