A disclosed computer-implemented method may include receiving a request to generate a dating profile for a user of a community-based dating service of a social networking system based on information associated with the user and maintained by the social networking system. The method may also include accessing information associated with the user and maintained by the social networking system. The method may additionally include selecting, from the information associated with the user and maintained by the social networking system (1) a set of contextual information associated with the user, and (2) a set of media items associated with the user. The method may further include generating the dating profile for the user by arranging the set of contextual information and the set of media items within a dating interface of the social networking system. Various other methods, systems, and computer-readable media are also disclosed.