An example method includes requesting, by a user device from a remote provider and from a local provider, candidate data for use in autofill for an application. The method further includes receiving a first data set from the remote provider and a second data set from the local provider. The method additionally includes detecting that an input field of the application has focus, where the input field is included in both sets. The method further includes responsively causing a selectable list to be displayed on the user device, where the selectable list includes a first selectable option corresponding to the first data set and a second selectable option corresponding to the second data set. The method also includes receiving user input data indicating a selected data set and responsively filling one or more candidate values from the selected data set into one or more corresponding input fields of the application.