An apparatus has a data storage structure to store data items tagged by respective tag values and stores, in association with each data item, a respective tag group identifier to identify other data items having a same tag value within a collection of data items. The apparatus also has tag match circuitry to identify one or more hitting data items. Prioritisation circuitry is provided to select candidate data items which, relative to any other data items in the particular collection of data items having the same tag group identifier as the selected candidate data item is favoured according to an ordering of the data items. The prioritisation circuitry selects the one or more candidate data items before the identification of the hitting data items is available from the tag match circuitry. Data item selection circuitry selects a candidate data item for which the tag match circuitry detected a match.