One or more engine instances are executed on each host to form an engine cluster. A plurality of control instances are executed on a first set of hosts to form a control cluster and comprise a control instance leader and one or more control instance followers. In response to a first host indicating a failure of a neighbor host, a pair-wise focused investigation is initiated to check peer-to-peer connections between the first host and the neighbor host. In response to one or more additional hosts indicating failures of neighbor hosts while the pair-wise focused investigation is being performed, a wide investigation is performed to check connections between the control cluster and the plurality of hosts. One or more hosts are added to an eviction list and an eviction protocol is performed to evict the one or more hosts from the engine cluster using the eviction list.