Systems for managing a retrieval of a prepared medication are provided. In one aspect, a system includes a memory that includes instructions, and one or more processors. The one or more processors is configured to execute the instructions to receive an identification of a plurality of unused medications and a current location of each of the plurality of unused medications, and determine an order in which to retrieve at least two of the plurality of unused medications and return the at least two of the plurality of unused medications to a return location. The one or more processors is also configured to execute the instructions to provide, for display, a listing of the at least two of the plurality of unused medications based on the order for retrieving the at least two of the plurality of unused medications. Methods and machine-readable media are also provided.