Described herein are allulose-containing baked good compositions containing allulose and leavening acids and baked goods made therefrom, as well as methods of making such compositions and baked goods. wherein one or more allulose-containing composition described herein reduces the browning caused by allulose in the allulose-containing baked goods made therefrom. The allulose-containing baked goods described herein have reduced added sugars and reduced caloric content as a result of the allulose replacing at least a portion of the nutritive sweetener (e.g., sugar) contained in a full sugar sweet baked good while beneficially addressing the undesirable color, and/or flavor changes that can result from allulose inclusion and without negative effects to textural characteristics.