A method enables creation of group highlights for consumers consuming media content at different locations/times. The method includes initiating consumer experience collage generation on a first electronic device. The method includes receiving, via a network interface from at least one second electronic device that can operate in a consumer experiencing capturing (CEC) mode, one or more images and at least one of a portion of a first media content or an associated time marker identifying a presentation time of the portion within the first media content. The method includes, in response to receiving the associated time marker, accessing a copy of the first media content and retrieving, based on the associated time marker, the portion of the first media content from the copy. The method includes generating a composite product comprising a combination of the at least one image and the portion of the first media content.