A processor includes a store queue and a store queue number assignment circuit. The store queue number assignment circuit assigns store queue numbers to stores, and operates upon instruction operations prior to the instruction operations reaching a point in the pipeline of the processor at which out of order instruction processing begins. Thus, store queue entries may be reserved for stores according to the program order of the stores. Additionally, in one embodiment, the store queue number identifying the youngest store represented in the store queue may be assigned to loads. In this manner, loads may determine which stores in the store queue are older or younger than the load based on relative position within the store queue. Checking for store queue hits may be qualified with the entries between the head of the store queue and the entry indicated by the load's store queue number. In one particular embodiment, the store queue number may include an additional “toggle” bit which is toggled each time the assignment of store queue numbers reaches the maximum store queue entry and wraps to zero. If the toggle bit of the store in the store queue entry identified by the load's store queue number differs from the toggle bit of the load's store queue number, than the store queue entry has been reassigned to a store younger than the load.