The present disclosure describes methods, systems, and computer program products for interactive authentication can include receiving a valid authentication credential or an invalid authentication credential associated with a digital identity. The credentials can be received from an end user at an input device in association with a login attempt. If a valid authentication credential is received, it is determined whether an identification token is received with the valid authentication credential. If received, the identification token is identified as a token included in a list of valid tokens associated with the digital identity at an authentication system. In response to the determination that the identification token is included in the list of valid tokens, it is determined whether a lockout period associated with the identification token in the list of valid tokens has expired. If expired, the end user associated with the login attempt can be authenticated.