Managing consistency of object replicas is performed at a first instance of a distributed storage system. The first instance performs garbage collection on a shard that includes a first plurality of object chunks, thereby removing a second plurality of object chunks from the shard. This leaves a third plurality of object chunks in the shard, where the first plurality of object chunks is the union of the second and third pluralities of object chunks. The first instance sends a first list of identifiers to a second instance of the distributed storage system. The second instance has a replica of the shard. The first list of identifiers specifies the object chunks in the third plurality of object chunks. The second instance removes all object chunks from the replica of the shard that are not included in the first list.