Systems and methods for search result replication in a search head cluster of a data aggregation and analysis system. An example method may comprise maintaining a replication count in a data store associated with at least one of the plurality of search heads, the replication count corresponding to how many of the replicas of the search result are stored in the search head cluster, determining that the replication count is greater than a target replication count, based on determining that the replication count is greater than the target replication count, initiating a deletion of at least one replica of the replicas of the search result from a target search head of the plurality of search heads storing the replicas, receiving an indication that the deletion is complete, and based on receiving the indication that the deletion is complete, decreasing the replication count corresponding to the search result.