Various aspects of the present disclosure generally relate to wireless communication. In some aspects, a user equipment (UE) may transmit, to a second user equipment, an indication of a time buffer threshold associated with providing sidelink hybrid automatic repeat request feedback on a physical sidelink feedback channel. The UE may receive, from the second user equipment, an indication of an agreement to use the time buffer threshold. The UE may transmit, to the second user equipment and based at least in part on the indication of the agreement, sidelink hybrid automatic repeat request feedback for a sidelink communication received from the second user equipment, the sidelink hybrid automatic repeat request feedback being transmitted on the physical sidelink feedback channel based at least in part on the time buffer threshold. Numerous other aspects are provided.