A beverage preparation appliance includes a housing having a base defining a cavity having an open side and a dispensing portion supported on the base and defining a beverage outlet location suspended above the base. The appliance further includes a drip tray body defining a perimeter side wall and an interior wall separating an interior of the tray body within the perimeter side wall into a reservoir area and a storage area. The drip tray body is partially received within the cavity of the base through the open side thereof with the storage area positioned within the cavity and at least a portion of the reservoir area being positioned outside the cavity underlying the beverage outlet location.