An effectively “conditional”, cast out operation or cast out portion of a combined operation including a related data access may be cancelled by the combined response to the operation. The combined response logic receives coherency state and/or LRU position information for cache lines corresponding to the cast out victim within snoopers and vertically in-line storage. The combined response logic may also receive information regarding the presence of shared or invalid cache lines in snoopers or lower level storage within the congruence class for the victim, or information regarding the read-once nature of the data access target. Based on these responses, the combined response logic determines whether the cast out should be cancelled and, if so, selects and drives the appropriate combined response code.