A tamper-evident cap (2) for engagement to a container closure plug (100), the cap including a panel (10) having a container closure plug-facing side and a preweakened region defining a tear strip (17), the tear strip having a tear strip pin (30) extending from the closure plug-facing side and configured for receipt by the container closure plug, a sidewall (12) extending from the closure plug-facing side, and a center post (20) extending axially from a central region of the panel, wherein the center post is configured to engage the container closure plug, the center post having a post preweakened region.