A toaster/oven accessory pan sized to cook small food items (eggs, etc.) comprises a flat major panel, integral upstanding sidewalls, a peripheral flange extending from and surrounding the sidewalls, and two handles integral with the peripheral flange and defining a slot opening for receiving the tines of a fork to lift and carry the pan. The bottoms of the fork tines engage a tab of the handle partially defining the slot opening, the tops of the fork tines engage a downstruck stiffening bead formed in the peripheral flange adjacent the slot opening and the ends of the tines abut a sidewall juxtaposed the handle. The peripheral flange is provided with grooves extending about two opposed corners and beads extending about the remaining two opposed corners, and a second identical toaster/oven accessory pan can be inverted and nest on the first pan as a cover, and in particular, the beads and grooves nest. The toaster/oven accessory pan is fabricated of aluminum, and both interior and exterior surfaces are coated with black Teflon, which is heat absorptive.