Methods and systems for enhancing the dynamic range of a high sensitivity inspection system are presented. The dynamic range of a high sensitivity inspection system is increased by directing a portion of the light collected from each pixel of the wafer inspection area toward an array of avalanche photodiodes (APDs) operating in Geiger mode and directing another portion of the light collected from each pixel of the wafer inspection area toward another array of photodetectors having a larger range. The array of APDs operating in Geiger mode is useful for inspection of surfaces that generate extremely low photon counts, while other photodetectors are useful for inspection of larger defects that generate larger numbers of scattered photons. In some embodiments, the detected optical field is split between two different detectors. In some other embodiments, a single detector includes both APDs operating in Geiger mode and other photodetectors having a larger range.