A method of making a compressible multilayer article includes a multilayer elastomeric laminate film article with a first adhesive tie layer on a first major surface of a first release liner; an elastomeric core layer including a cured silicone polymer onto a surface of the first adhesive tie layer; a second adhesive tie layer on a first major surface of the elastomeric core layer; and a second release liner on a major surface of the second adhesive tie layer. A selected portion of each of the second release liner, the second adhesive tie layer, the elastomeric core layer, and the first adhesive tie layer is separated from the multilayer elastomeric laminate film article to form a patterned multilayer elastomeric film article including an array compressible structures attached to the first release liner, and an array of chaff regions attached to the first release liner and interspersed between the compressible structures.